Why Choose Asphalt Shingles Versus Metal Roofs?

Both asphalt shingles and metal roofs have pros and cons that you should weigh before deciding where to put your money. Metal roofs are preferable because they are recyclable. They are environmental friendly.

Asphalt shingles wear and tear after use, so you can recycle them. Metal roofs also enhance energy efficiency since they readily reflect sunlight and reduce the amount of heat reaching the building interior. You can save more money for your utility bill with a metal roof than asphalt shingles.

There is no denying the beauty of asphalt shingles as they come in luxurious designs and styles. Asphalt shingles are preferable for their elegant appearance and affordability.

However, thanks to innovation, metal roofs are now available in varying options. The variety of metal roofs also gives you multiple alternatives to consider. You will have to cough more dollars for choice metal options, such as copper. Regardless, metal roofs might appear inappropriate in some neighbourhoods.

Despite the many benefits of metal roofs, they are certainly expensive than asphalt shingles in terms of the upfront cost. However, metal roofs are cheaper in the long term, therefore, offer more return on investment guarantees. Metal roofs last longer (over 50 years) while asphalt shingles can only serve for 15 to 20 years.

If the metal roof rusts or undergoes degradation, you can paint over it or seal it to improve the aesthetic appeal and durability. Using oily paints will also prevent the metal roof from rusting, as it keeps moisture away. 

Comparing asphalt shingles versus metal roof

Why go for asphalt shingles
  • They offer the visual appeal for colour, tone, and style consistency.
  • It is more affordable and the installation cost is lower. 
  • Although Affinity Roofing advises against DIYing a roofing structure, asphalt shingles are easier to install for a layman. 
Why go for a metal roof
  • Metal roofs are available in a variety of options in terms of colour and format. You can get shingles, ribbed, tiles, or panels.
  • Metal roofs come with a longer life expectancy.
  • Metal is greener, since it is more energy efficient.
  • Metal roofs are lightweight, but super strong for durability.
  • Metal roofs offer more water, hail, fire, and wind resistance.
Metal roofs are available in a variety of options in terms of colour and format.
You can get shingles, ribbed, tiles, or panels.
Metal roofs come with a longer life expectancy.
Metal is greener, since it is more energy efficient.
Metal roofs are lightweight, but super strong for durability.
Metal roofs offer more water, hail, fire, and wind resistance.

Sam hill - Owner and chief cook in Cripton